In a depressed investment environment, the use of reliable income streams when constructing a portfolio remains prudent
Inflation is set to continue rising in 2012 while economic growth is slowing. In this environment, meaningful capital appreciation will be hard to come by, further emphasising the need to use appropriately priced and reliable income streams when constructing a portfolio to plan for income today or income in the future.
The inflation rate influences interest rates and forms the benchmark for real returns. Consumer spending is paramount for corporate profitability and growing dividends. Consequently, these are two of the most important macro-economic variables to consider when determining an appropriate price to pay for an income stream.
2011 was characterised by rising inflation and a fatigued consumer. The combination of rising inflation and slowing household consumption, as well as on-going uncertainties surrounding the Eurozone sovereign debt crisis resulted in volatile markets with prices ending the year at similar levels to where they started. Markets were volatile throughout 2011 with no price appreciation: positive total return was purely a function of income.
In 2012 the challenges remain: austerity measures will be a drag on global economic growth for years to come
2012 is set to be another trying year for investors. Over-indebtedness of many first world economies has forced authorities in these regions to reduce fiscal deficits by lowering spending and increasing taxes (austerity measures). This cutback in spending is expected to be a drag on global economic growth for many years to come. A debt-to-GDP ratio of 60% is often noted as a prudent limit for developed countries and the table below highlights just how elevated the government debt levels are in first world economies:
| Country |
Debt to GDP (2011 Estimated)
|
| Italy |
128%
|
| France |
99%
|
| US |
98%
|
| UK |
90%
|
| Spain |
74%
|
Source: OECD
One third of SA’s exports go to the Eurozone and the US
South Africa will not be immune to first world developments as it relies on developed markets for international trade as demonstrated in the table below:
| Country |
% of SA exports
|
| Eurozone |
25%
|
| China |
14%
|
| United States |
10%
|
| Japan |
9%
|
| India |
4%
|
Source: Department of Trade and Industry
An additional headwind for SA economic growth is a consumer who remains over-indebted and under-saved. This, combined with declining real house prices and a high level of unemployment, has weighed on consumer confidence throughout 2011.
Chart 1: Key Consumer Statistics as at December 2011
Source: I-Net
The problem with too much debt
With the availability of debt, accumulated savings are no longer a prerequisite for consumption. Debt is used by consumers to bring forward the consumption of big ticket items such as housing, household appliances and motor vehicles.
Household consumption makes up approximately 60% of South Africa’s Gross Domestic Expenditure (GDE) and is the biggest driver of GDP growth. Thus, whilst households are accumulating debt to fund consumption, an economy will experience strong economic growth.
However, an unfortunate trade-off exists. As household debt accumulates, more and more future income is diverted away from consumption as it must be used to service and payback debt. Thus when debt levels reach a ceiling, consumption slows thus detracting from GDP growth.
Local inflation is set to continue rising which, together with low growth, suggests SA income streams relative to first world alternatives are expensive
Despite a slowing economy, local inflation is set to continue rising as SA is yet to feel the full impact of a weaker rand. Almost one third of South Africa’s GDE consists of imports, thus the rand’s 22% depreciation against the US dollar during 2011 will exert significant upward pressure on inflation in the months ahead as import costs rise.
An environment characterised by rising inflation and subdued dividend growth suggests that the current low dividend yields of many South African asset classes cannot be justified. Internationally, first world markets are offering investors substantially better value.
Where to invest in 2012?
SA Bonds – inflation-linked bonds are preferred
We continue to favour inflation-linked bonds over fixed interest bonds due to their relatively attractive real yields and inflation-hedged income. Based on our current medium term inflation estimate of at least 7% p.a., the real return offered by fixed interest bonds is about 1% which is less attractive than inflation-linked bonds which are currently guaranteeing investors a real return of 2.2%.
SA Listed Property – below average yields and below average income growth
Administered prices continue to escalate well ahead of inflation and their impact on property expenses is starting to significantly subdue the income growth prospects of SA listed property.
As a result of subdued property distribution growth prospects, investors should be compensated with higher yields than are currently available in the market.
SA Money Market Instruments – a parking bay to preserve capital
Despite rising inflation, cash interest rates during 2011 remained unchanged. The outlook for interest rates for the year ahead is uncertain as it remains unclear to what extent the governor of the Reserve Bank, Gill Marcus, will favour stimulating economic growth over combating inflation.
SA Listed Equities – low dividend yields
Although dividends generated by South African companies increased by approximately 31% during the course of 2011, the average dividend growth since 2008 has been approximately -1%.
This recovery in dividends, coupled with minimal share price appreciation has resulted in the dividend yields of South African equities increasing from 2.2% at the beginning of 2011 to 2.9% today. Despite this, local equity yields in general remain well below their long term historic averages. To justify current valuations, South African companies must continue to produce above average dividend growth, but this appears highly unlikely given slowing global economic growth and a strained SA consumer.
International markets
International real estate continues to offer investors fair yields with inflation-hedged income growth prospects. Due to historically low interest rates, the probability of any real return from an investment in international fixed interest bonds is unlikely.
First world large cap stocks continue to offer good value. Dividend yields of some of the largest and most recognisable companies in the world remain well above their long term historic averages, as well as being higher than international bond yields, cash interest rates and inflation. It should be noted that these first world large cap equities operate globally and derive a substantial portion of their revenues from emerging markets as demonstrated in the table below:
First World Large Cap Companies with Emerging Market Exposure (2011)
| Company |
Emerging Market Exposure
|
| British American Tobacco |
42%
|
| Unilever |
40%
|
| Proctor & Gamble |
34%
|
| Vodafone |
29%
|
| GlaxoSmithKline |
27%
|
| Johnson & Johnson |
18%
|
Source: Company Financials
Conclusion
In a time of heightened market volatility where the outlook for investments appears discouraging, it remains possible for investors to obtain a high degree of certainty in planning for income today or income in the future. Investors should seek opportunities which expose them to consistent and reliable income streams, enabling them to accumulate and grow capital in preparation for retirement and preserve capital during their retired years.
Marriott Asset Management